Animal Rights?
( Moral Rights vs Lawful Rights)
This may make some people mad but technically, animals don't automatically have "rights".  "Rights" can only be given by man. Even God couldn't bring himself to bestow "rights" on man... in as much as what would have been the point if he couldn't have 
backed them up? That is to say:  Almost all of mankind has had no "rights" at one time 
or another.  Most were slaves to each other since the beginning of time, and even today, there are many things that we have no "right" to do (like abuse people or animals)....but those rights are given by man in the form of laws.  Then and only then do people and animals have "rights".  For instance, the  natives in South America still kill and eat precious Hyacinth Macaws.  Do they have the right to do this as they have since the beginning of time?  Well, until man steps in and outlaws the practice... you bet they do.  Now, a 
moralist might say that all living things have a "right" to live. And they'd be right also. But as the word "Rights" itself has been abused to the point of reflecting little of it's original intention,  we've gone far beyond morals, and use the term "Rights" as in a court of law.  When used this way, no animal can petition a court of law for "rights"...... but man can, and does.  For instance, the eagle has "rights" and is protected by law to back up those rights.  The common pigeon on the other hand has no "rights" in most states.   I personally think that large parrots have the moral "right" to fly free as they were intended, not cooped up in a cage. But man (through laws) gave me the "right" to lock them up forever.  Does that make it morally right??   No... not in my book!  But lawfully yes.  So we all have been
deciding since the beginning of time,  what's to be killed and eaten, or killed as being a pest.  We have also decided what's valuable to us and needs protection.

Hopefully we can continue to change the laws in order that no animal suffers,
by bestowing upon that creature the "right" to live properly.

Sorry about the diatribe.... I get carried away sometimes.

Back to Opinion page

E-mail